Following its opening in the summer of 1999, Golf Digest ranked Limestone Springs as one of the top 10 Upscale Golf Course Designs in the United States. Golf Digest and Golfweek continue to give Limestone Springs well deserved accolades.
- No. 1 Rated Public Access Course in Alabama 2004, 2006-2009 – GolfWeek Magazine
- Top 5 Courses in Alabama 2001-2008 – GolfWeek Magazine
- Rated 4.5 Stars 2002-2009 – Golf Digest Magazine
- Top 10 Public Access under 2000 Rounds 2003-2004 – Golf Digest Magazine
- #77 in Top 100 Public Golf Courses in America 2003-2004 – Golf Digest Magazine
- #1 Public Access and Resort Category Course in Alabama 2003,2004,2006,2007 – Golf Digest Magazine
- Best Course in Alabama 2004 – Golf Digest Magazine
- #64 of America’s 100 Greatest Public Golf Courses 2005 – Golf Digest Magazine
- America’s Top Golf Courses 2004-2008 – Zagat’s Survey
- #5 Best Golf Course (private &/or public) in Alabama 2005 – Golf Digest Magazine
- #2 America’s Best: State-By-State Public Access Courses 2005 – GolfWeek Magazine
- Nation’s Top 10 Newest Courses 1999 – Golf Digest Magazine
- Best Overall Value Public Golf Course 2005 – Birmingham Magazine
- Best Golf Value in Alabama 2005 – Alabama Live Magazine
- Best Places to Play in Alabama for Buddy Trips 2007 – T + L Golf
- No. 85 Best Residential Golf Courses in America 2007 – GolfWeek
- 2013 Top Ten Best Public Courses in Alabama – GolfWeek
- 2014 Top Ten Best Public Courses in Alabama – GolfWeek
